Dammed if You Do: Should the Government Be Liable for Hurricane Flooding and Other Natural Disasters?

Lior Jacob Strahilevitz

Abstract

When hurricanes, wildfires, and other natural disasters strike, government officials must make difficult decisions under time pressure and amidst uncertainty over how best to save lives and mitigate the resulting damage to private property. Sometimes landowners who do not second-guess the appropriateness of those decisions made in exigent circumstances nonetheless insist that the government should foot the bill for the resulting destruction. In a 2025 opinion (Ablan) and a 2022 decision (Milton), both involving flooding damage resulting from Hurricane Harvey, the Federal Circuit articulated an expansive vision of government liability under the Takings Clause that can be squared with neither Supreme Court authority on the relationship between takings and trespass torts, nor the scope of the government’s necessity defense. The Federal Circuit also endorsed two propositions that are out of step with foundational premises in the United States’ constitutional order: the notion that the Bill of Rights vindicates positive liberties as well as negative liberties, and the idea that landowners lack constructive notice of prior publicized government actions concerning their property. On remand, the Court of Federal Claims has found the federal government responsible under the Takings Clause for the flooding of upstream homes built inside a floodplain and also liable for downstream flooding that the government initiated in order to prevent much graver harm to both downstream owners and upstream owners. Taken together, Ablan and Milton represent the worst Takings Clause decisions of the 2000s. This article explains how these courts went astray, why the defenses of the judges’ sudden break with the past do not hold water, how these errors undermine longstanding core features of property doctrine, and why these missteps will create perverse incentives for both governments and landowners in various contexts involving foreseeable calamities.