As cyberattacks increase in frequency and intensity around the globe, private actors have turned to more innovative cyber defense strategies. For many, this involves considering the use of cutting-edge active cyber defense measures—that is, tactics beyond merely erecting firewalls and installing antivirus software that permit cyber defenders to detect and respond to threats in real time. The legality of such measures under international law is a subject of intense debate because of definitional uncertainty surrounding what qualifies as an “active” cyber defense measure. This Comment argues that active defense measures that do not rise to the level of a cybercrime are permissible under international law. Accordingly, it analyzes the Budapest Convention, the only binding international instrument related to cybercrime, and uses its definition of illegal conduct under international law to construct a “stoplight framework” to guide cyber defenders in their actions. Ultimately, this Comment concludes that cyber defenders have a “green light” to use purely passive measures, such as monitoring one’s own network traffic, because these measures are highly unlikely to involve conduct the Budapest Convention criminalizes. Active-passive measures, such as attaching code to intruders that tracks them back to their home base, can in some cases be justified under exceptions to the Convention; accordingly, cyber defenders should proceed with caution. Finally, outright active defense measures nearly always rise to the level of offense conduct under the Budapest Convention, and should not be used. This analysis provides needed clarity as to the legality of conduct in cyberspace, and provides cyber defenders with the guideposts they need to confidently innovate in today’s complex cyber landscape
Van Dine, Alexandra
"When is Cyber Defense a Crime? Evaluating ActiveCyber Defense Measures Under theBudapest Convention,"
Chicago Journal of International Law:
2, Article 18.
Available at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil/vol20/iss2/18